Can I Apply for U.S. Citizenship with an Expired Permanent Resident Card?

The journey to becoming a U.S. citizen can be filled with questions and concerns, particularly when dealing with the complexities of immigration policies. One common query among permanent residents is whether they can apply for U.S. citizenship if their Green Card has expired. In this article, we will provide a thorough understanding of the issue and guide you through the process of applying for citizenship with an expired Green Card.

2. Understanding U.S. Citizenship and Permanent Residency (Green Card)

Before diving into the specifics of applying for citizenship with an expired Green Card, let’s clarify the fundamental differences between U.S. citizenship and permanent residency.

U.S. Citizenship

U.S. citizenship is the process of becoming a full-fledged citizen of the United States by virtue of birth or naturalization. Upon obtaining citizenship, individuals gain numerous rights and benefits, such as:

The right to vote in federal, state, and local elections
The ability to hold certain public offices and government jobs
The privilege of applying for a U.S. passport and enjoying visa-free travel to numerous countries
Protection from deportation
The ability to sponsor family members for immigration more easily

Permanent Residency (Green Card)

On the other hand, permanent residency, commonly known as a Green Card, grants foreign nationals the right to live, work, and study in the United States indefinitely. Although permanent residents enjoy certain benefits, they also face some limitations, such as:

Inability to vote in federal, state, and local elections
Potential risk of deportation if they commit certain criminal offenses or violate immigration laws
Restrictions on the length of time they can spend outside the U.S. without jeopardizing their status
Limited ability to sponsor family members for immigration compared to U.S. citizens

3. Requirements for Applying for U.S. Citizenship

Understanding the eligibility criteria for U.S. citizenship is vital before submitting an application for naturalization. Factors such as age, good moral character, and residency requirements play a critical role in determining whether an individual meets the necessary conditions for citizenship. In this section, we will explore these eligibility requirements and delve into the overall naturalization process.

Eligibility Criteria for U.S. Citizenship

To apply for U.S. citizenship, applicants must meet specific requirements, as outlined by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). The primary eligibility criteria include:

Age: Applicants must be at least 18 years old.
Residency: Permanent residents (Green Card holders) must have resided continuously in the United States for at least five years (three years if married to a U.S. citizen). Additionally, they must have maintained their primary residence in the same state or jurisdiction as their application for naturalization.
Physical Presence: Applicants must have been physically present in the U.S. for at least 30 months out of the five years preceding their application (18 months out of the three years for those married to a U.S. citizen).
Good Moral Character: Individuals must exhibit good moral character, adhering to the principles of the U.S. Constitution and avoiding criminal behavior or other actions that could disqualify them.
Basic Knowledge of U.S. History and Government: Applicants must pass a civics test demonstrating their understanding of U.S. history and government structure.
English Language Proficiency: Fluency in reading, writing, and speaking basic English is mandatory, as applicants must pass an English language test.
Oath of Allegiance: Naturalization entails taking an Oath of Allegiance, pledging loyalty to the United States and renouncing any foreign allegiances.

The Naturalization Process and Application Requirements

After confirming their eligibility, applicants can initiate the naturalization process by taking the following steps:

Complete Form N-400: Individuals must submit the Application for Naturalization (Form N-400), which includes information about the applicant’s background, residency, and other relevant details.
Submit Documentation: Along with the N-400 form, applicants must provide supporting documents such as their Green Card, tax returns, and proof of continuous residence.
Undergo a Biometrics Appointment: USCIS will require the applicant’s fingerprints, photographs, and signatures for security and identification purposes.
Attend an Interview: A USCIS officer will conduct a one-on-one interview to assess the applicant’s qualifications, review their application, and administer the English language and civics tests.
Receive a Decision: USCIS will notify the applicant of the approval or denial of their application based on the results of their interview and assessment of eligibility.
Take the Oath of Allegiance: If granted citizenship, the applicant will participate in a naturalization ceremony, administering the Oath of Allegiance to become a U.S. citizen.

4. The Expiration of Permanent Resident Cards (Green Cards)

Understanding the expiration and renewal process of Permanent Resident Cards is crucial for lawful permanent residents looking to maintain their legal status in the United States. In this section, we will discuss the validity period of Green Cards, consequences of having an expired card, and tips for the renewal or replacement process.

Validity Period of Green Cards and Reasons for Expiration

A standard Green Card typically has a validity period of 10 years for permanent residents and two years for conditional permanent residents. However, one’s permanent resident status does not necessarily expire with the card. Card expiration primarily serves as a security measure and facilitates updates of personal information and card technology.

Consequences of Having an Expired Green Card

Possessing an expired Green Card can lead to complications, including:

Difficulties finding employment, as employers are mandated to verify the eligibility of new hires using a valid, unexpired Green Card
Inability to prove lawful permanent resident status, leading to potential issues when returning to the U.S. after international travel
Obstacles in applying for certain public benefits that require proof of valid permanent resident status

Tips on Renewing or Replacing a Green Card

To avoid complications, it is essential to renew or replace an expired or soon-to-expire Green Card by taking the following steps:

File Form I-90: Submit the Application to Replace Permanent Resident Card (Form I-90) either online or via mail to renew or replace your Green Card.
Provide Required Documentation: Include supporting documents such as a copy of the expired Green Card or government-issued identification to verify your identity.
Undergo a Biometrics Appointment: Attend a biometrics appointment if required by USCIS for fingerprinting, photograph, and signature purposes.
Obtain Temporary Proof of Status: If needed, request a temporary stamp (I-551) at your local USCIS office to prove your permanent resident status while awaiting your new Green Card.

5. Can I Apply for U.S. Citizenship with an Expired Green Card?

Understanding the possibilities and potential consequences of applying for U.S. citizenship with an expired Green Card requires careful examination of USCIS policies and regulations. In this section, we will discuss these regulations, provide examples of cases where applying with an expired Green Card is possible, and warn of any related consequences or challenges.

Analyzing USCIS Policies and Regulations

While USCIS does not explicitly state that an unexpired Green Card is required to apply for U.S. citizenship, the agency does advise applicants to renew their Green Card before filing the naturalization application so that they can provide proof of their continuous permanent resident status. This ultimately depends on the discretion of the USCIS officer handling the case.

Examples of Cases Where Applying with an Expired Green Card is Possible

Although it is generally recommended to renew an expired Green Card before applying for citizenship, there are cases where those with expired cards have been successful in obtaining citizenship. These situations often include applicants with otherwise strong citizenship applications, multiple supporting documents to verify their identity, and continuous residence in the United States.

Potential Consequences or Challenges of Applying with an Expired Green Card

Applying for citizenship with an expired Green Card may pose various challenges, including:

The USCIS officer may request that you renew your Green Card before proceeding with the naturalization application, potentially delaying the application process.
Difficulty proving continuous residence and lawful permanent resident status, leading to possible denial of citizenship
In some cases, failure to renew an expired Green Card may be interpreted as a lackadaisical attitude towards maintaining permanent resident status, which could negatively impact the chances of obtaining citizenship.

6. How to Renew Your Green Card and Proceed with U.S. Citizenship Application

If your permanent resident card (Green Card) has expired, it’s essential to renew it before applying for U.S. citizenship. In this section, we will discuss the steps to renew your Green Card and the reasons why starting the renewal process as soon as possible is crucial.

Steps to Renew an Expired Green Card

To renew your expired Green Card, follow these steps:

File Form I-90: Submit an Application to Replace Permanent Resident Card (Form I-90) with the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). This form can be filed online or by mail, depending on your preference.
Submit Supporting Documentation: Along with Form I-90, include a copy of your expired Green Card or other evidence of your permanent resident status. If applicable, also provide additional documents that support your application, such as name change evidence or updated information.
Pay the Filing Fee: As of October 2, 2020, the filing fee for Form I-90 is $455, with an additional biometric services fee of $85 for applicants under 79 years old. Check the USCIS Fee Schedule to confirm the current fees.
Attend a Biometrics Appointment: If required, USCIS will schedule a biometrics appointment for you to provide your fingerprints, photograph, and signature.
Receive Your New Green Card: After processing your application and verifying your information, USCIS will issue a new Green Card with an extended validity period.

Processing Times and Fees

Green Card renewal processing times can vary widely, typically taking between 5 and 12 months. It’s crucial to plan accordingly and not wait until the last minute to renew your card. Keep in mind that processing times can change, so regularly check the USCIS Processing Times website for updated information.

Importance of Beginning the Renewal Process Early

Starting the Green Card renewal process as soon as possible is critical due to several reasons:

Avoid complications: Submitting your citizenship application with an expired Green Card may cause delays, and USCIS may request that you renew your card before proceeding with your citizenship application.
Maintain proof of status: A valid Green Card is essential to prove your lawful permanent resident status, which might be necessary for employment or travel purposes.
Minimize risks: If your Green Card is expired and you haven’t initiated the renewal process, you may face difficulties proving your legal status, potentially leading to complications or temporary loss of certain rights.

7. Conclusion

In summary, it is possible to apply for U.S. citizenship with an expired Green Card, but doing so is not advisable. To avoid potential complications, it’s essential to renew your Green Card (using Form I-90) and then apply for citizenship through the naturalization process. By understanding the steps involved in renewing your Green Card and the associated fees and processing times, you can minimize any delays or difficulties in your path to becoming a U.S. citizen.